Scroll down for Candidates Responses to our Questionnaire
Print friendly version
We want you to VOTE!
Health Action Trust mailed each Nelson City Council, Tasman District Council, and DHB candidate seven questions focused on youth health issues, namely: alcohol harm minimisation,
the drinking age & legal status of cannabis in NZ,
differences between decriminalisation and legalisation of cannabis,
Maori health service provision, and
consumer involvement in mental health services.
Finally we asked what priority candidates gave Health Promotion.
Below are their responses; most are reported verbatim, a small number are abridged.
Even though this page was done a few years back, some of these people are still around,
so read on to see what they think...
NB. YP = keyboard abbreviation for "Young People."
Results from a mailed questionnaire to NCC, TDC & DHB candidates, as received by 20-09-01.
<!-- ------------------------- --><!-- END OF CONVERTED OUTPUT --><!-- ------------------------- -->
Name
Candidate for ...
1. What would you do to minimise alcohol-related harm for young people in this region?
2. What stance do you take regarding the review of the drinking age (Sale of Liquor Act) ?
3. What do you think the legal status of cannabis should be in NZ?
4. What do you see as the differences between decriminalisation and legalisation of cannabis?
5. What is your view on Maori health service provision in the Nelson region?
6. What is your view on consumer involvement in mental health?
7. What priority do you give health promotion for the well-being of New Zealanders?
Other comments
Alan Drummond verbatim
NCC
Build the regional leisure pool, plus other amenities that would appeal to the young. I have two sons in the Nelson Police force and am well aware of the problems.
It is patently clear that a large proportion of NZ youth cannot handle alcohol as is evidenced in our streets at weekends. The age should be taken back to 20.
I believe that cannabis is much more harmful than many would have us believe. I do know that regular use has a cumulative residual effect. The effect on the young can be catastrophic. It should not be legalised.
The former would lead to the latter
I am not aware that Maori do not have the same access or care than any other group.
A day care centre seems eminently sensible
Diet.
Pride in your city & surroundings is very important.
Alan Turley verbatim
NCC
Limit the sale of alcohol & get tougher.
It should be changed back up to 20 years and over.
Cannabis is an addiction like smoking and alcohol. It should be treated as an addiction and not as a crime. People should be helped.
Cannabis should not be legalised, but possession of cannabis, like cigarettes and Alcohol should not be a crime. The product should remain illegal.
I don't support preferential health treatment for any ethnic group. Availability of health treatment should be on the basis of individual need and not race.
Good, providing it doesn't provide a financial cop-out for central govt responsibilities in this area.
A high priority providing it is properly structured.
Health services are not a City Council issue. [These] views are purely personal.
Allan Griffiths verbatim
NCC
You will be aware that there will be many issues facing prospective Councillors that we will be asked to comment on. I believe it would not be appropriate for me to pass comment on any of the questions you have asked until fully conversant of the facts.
Andy Clark verbatim
TDC Golden Bay
Stricter controls on access to alcohol by YP. Through mentoring, try & highlight to YP healthier ways of getting kicks and having fun. In the classroom, using real people rather than teachers, try to undo the spell to conform which capitalism & commercialism put's YP under.
I am not happy with the apparent effect of dropping the drinking age, but I'm unsure whether the main problem is enforcement of the law or the law itself. Without additional facts I am loathe to make a call on the review. I feel the problem is a social/cultural one not a legal one which makes it doubly difficult to address.
Decriminalise only.
As much as I don't condone the use of cannabis, the inconsistencies in societies/governments rules over the use/abuse of widely used substances, tobacco, alcohol, cannabis is unfair and should be rectified, as much by stricter controls on the 2 legal substances as lessening controls on cannabis.
I have insufficient knowledge on the issue to comment.
I'm a little unsure as to the intent of the question but generally consumers would always have a role to play in anything that is provided for them. Presumably there would be a few consumers in the mental health area who may not have the ability to be involved.
I feel health promotion, including non-traditional aspects of health should get a greater slice of the Health budget. The amount of money spent on the last 5 years of an individual's life is verging on criminal.
Anne Turley verbatim
DHB
Education. Raise the drinking age back up to 20 years - ID essential. Limit the sale of alcohol. Actively prosecute those who sell liquor to anyone under age.
Raise it up to 20 years.
Cannabis smoking is an addiction like smoking tobacco and alcoholism. People need help to stop it. Treat it as a disease not a crime.
Cannabis should not be legalised. Possession of cannabis, like cigarettes and alcohol should not be a crime. These drugs are all harmful.
They receive preferential health treatment compared with other ethnic groups. Availability of health treatment should be based on NEED not RACE. Provision should be where the needs are.
Good.
A high priority.
Babbie Joyce verbatim
NCC
Promote education and encourage development of good self-image.
Age is not necessarily the factor. Responsibility and sound judgement must be taken into consideration.
Should be illegal.
It comes down to the same thing. No real differences.
Very worthwhile. Everyone needs good health care.
I support consumer involvement in Mental Health.
I feel promoting health and well-being to be a very high priority for all New Zealanders.
Barry Cashman verbatim
TDC Golden Bay
Increase the drinking age.
I believe it should be increased and penalties enforced on suppliers.
Remain as it is.
None.
Quite satisfactory
When communities have suitable facilities in place I feel it is [working ... well? illegible writing] although there are some terrible cases where patients should not be free in the community.
Very high priority.
Brett Ricketts verbatim
One person can do very little, but would encourage education and participation with programmes and events targeted at YP that has a message that life can be fun without the potential for harm that excesses cause. Initiatives should be driven by YP and those community groups working in the area of youth health etc.
We have an 18 age threshold now. I don't think going back would work. We need better education and enforcement.
Partially decriminalised.
Opposed to legalisation but have some sympathy for decriminalisation for small, experimentation type situations. Not keen on seeing YP end up with a police record for what may be a one-off situation. Given Cannabis related problems, society should not encourage it's use.
Targeted promotion for groups/diseases as required.
As Chairman of WCT [?] I feel strongly that consumers should be involved and not just represented. Who better to indicate what works or not.
High - But I think a lot of health promotion currently misses the boat. Lots of money spent for nebulous results. Let's hear what NZ want to know (and don't want to know) and package the message accordingly.
Brian Say verbatim
DHB Tasman
The occurrence of alcohol-related harm is best addressed through an education process. I would support projects which aim to educate youth concerning the adverse effects of alcohol use.
The raising/lowering of the drinking age does not appear to be effective in controlling alcohol-related harm. The laws at present are in line with the age of majority and I would support education projects
The use and growing of Cannabis is illegal. Medical evidence has shown that using Cannabis is detrimental to the health of the individual. The current status of the Law should remain the same, unless compelling evidence promotes a review of that status.
Decriminalisation - Is the limited use of Cannabis by the individual for his/her personal use only. Legalisation - may allow the use, growing and sale of Cannabis on an unrestricted basis.
Maori suffer disproportionately from diseases such as Diabetes, heart problems etc. Improvement in lowering the incidence of these diseases can only come about by supporting and educating groups at risk in how lifestyle changes can improve health outcomes for Maori. I would support such initiatives to address these problems.
By "the consumer" I take it you mean the "User" of Mental Health Services. Normally we expect individuals to participate and take responsibility for their treatment. Whether that is always possible with a mentally ill patient is questionable. I know that compliance in taking medication is not always 100%. Some form of monitoring and/or supervision is therefore necessary if we are to avoid the consequences of lapses in a medication regime.
As you can see from my responses above, I am an advocate of Health Promotion for improving the health of all New Zealanders in the long term. From that perspective I would give health promotion initiatives a high priority.
Name
Candidate for ...
1. What would you do to minimise alcohol-related harm for young people in this region?
2. What stance do you take regarding the review of the drinking age (Sale of Liquor Act) ?
3. What do you think the legal status of cannabis should be in NZ?
4. What do you see as the differences between decriminalisation and legalisation of cannabis?
5. What is your view on Maori health service provision in the Nelson region?
6. What is your view on consumer involvement in mental health?
7. What priority do you give health promotion for the well-being of New Zealanders?
Other comments
Brian Smythe verbatim
DHB
Expect/encourage parents and caregivers to be responsible. Enforce age restrictions at liquor sales outlets. Support educational programmes. Lobby for increase of legal drinking age back to 20
While enforcement of age restrictions is difficult to administer, lowering the age from 20 to 18 appears to have carried significant adverse effects. Raising the age again to 20 may assist the problem.
Assuming cannabis use, especially by the young, can cause severe mental and physical impairment and permanent damage, I would favour a cautious regulatory law reducing penalties for first-time and adult users, while retaining harsh penalties for dealers.
Decriminalisation - reducing the penalty regime to a similar level to petty traffic offences. Legalisation - removing all criminal consequences and stigma from cannabis use (presumably permitting growth and distribution as legitimate activity).
There are eight iwi in Te Tau Ihu. There are some Maori cultural issues (e.g. removal of body tissue outside NZ) requiring a degree of sensitivity. However in general Maori have equal access to all health services. Research may reveal a significant need for assistance, as in transport, welfare benefits etc.
This is a highly specialist and most difficult issue of which I have only general understanding. The issue of allocation of resources, and inappropriate release of the mentally ill is clearly one of current governmental concern.
Obviously prevention is better than cure. Good dietary and exercise habits must continue to be encouraged. Education programmes will always assist. Resources should be allocated in these areas.
Bruce Dyer verbatim
NCC
* There is a need for more education of young people and their parents to alcohol-related harm. * The "Smoke-free" campaign has been targetting smoking. There could well be a place for an "alcohol-free" campaign. * More rigorously enforce the need for teenagers buying alcohol especially from liquor outlets to carry ID * Promote activities such as yoga and meditation that eschew consumption of liquor and drugs.
Given that the lowered drinking age has meant that people who are too young to buy are now getting liquor bought by their older peers, it would seem appropriate to revisit the need for raising the drinking age. Revisiting could involve researching the situation.so that we knew what is going on.
Because it's use is widespread it would seem helpful to consider limited decriminalisation. With Police turning a blind eye eg at The Gathering this is effectively what is happening already.
Decriminalisation means that cannabis use/growing is not condoned across the board. Legalisation means that there would be no restrictions on its use, growing and sale.
Need to provide resources to educate more Maori as health providers for their community.
Depending on their capacity consumers should be encouraged to become self-reliant.
Cheaper to encourage people to take responsibility for their health than picking them up at the bottom of the cliff.
Chris Tuffnel abridged.
DHB Richmond
...The use of alcohol is a personal decision and I believe our focus in minimising the impact of alcohol on our community should be information and education to convince people of the harm alcohol can do to them and their friends/family. The Health Action website suggests some of the ways that alcohol-related harm can be minimised e.g.. safe partying. ... It is important that there is early detection of conduct disorders and this can be facilitated through good links between education services and public health nurses...
I don't believe there is anything to be gained from lowering the drinking age from 18 years.
I believe using Cannabis for recreational use should be decriminalised, however, there should be substantial controls on its cultivation, distribution, production, and sale in New Zealand - as there are for many other potentially harmful plants and substances. Again, information and education, based on credible research, should be the key strategy for discouraging people from using Cannabis recreationally. In regard to Cannabis use for medical reasons, e.g.. pain relief, there are other suitable alternatives available, however there may be some argument for Cannabis being available on prescription.
~
I have some understanding of Maori Health and Rongoa Maori but have not worked specifically in the area of Maori Health. I have worked in partnership with a Maori auditor in auditing Health and Disability Advocacy Services in New Zealand. ... The NMDHB Statement of Intent Jan 2001 - June 2001 states clear strategies for working with iwi & other Maori, including development of Maori providers & design of programmes and services specifically for Maori. I would support these initiatives but would also like to see the Board[base ']s Balanced Score Card include some key performance measures re Maori Health.
I totally support consumer involvement in mental health. A key challenge is to make it safe for people experiencing poor care or infringements of their rights to be heard without fear or repercussion and for action to be taken to address their concerns.
... I think we have to be very careful that the Primary Care Strategy does not get hi-jacked and result in just a reshuffle of primary medical care. Healthcare is much, more than medical care - and it is time to tip the scales in favour of proactive health care rather than reactive primary medical care. Health promotion and prevention of poor health is everyone[base ']s responsibility, - we have to start tackling it at the personal level. Self care (or individuals and families) is something that has not really been addressed in the current health system. First contact care also needs further development so that people have a range of choices. Big community or group programmes are only part of the answer to health promotion.
Colleen Marshall verbatim
TDC Mayoral
Education, through schools and media. Return the legal age for drinking to 20. Provide better quality facilities for YP. Engage youth in decision -making for communities.
I should like to see the drinking age raised.
Cannabis is a dangerous accumulative drug. I would not like to see it's use become legal.
Decriminalisation means that indulging in the use of cannabis is not a criminal act. Legalisation means it is readily available through commercial outlets as are cigarettes.
Access should be democratic ! Support for Marae/iwi/whanau/health initiatives is important.
-
Preventative health should be the key to health promotion for the well-being of Nzers. High priority - everyone is affected by health infrastructure - access.
Cynthia McConville verbatim
NCC
Provide funding to promote the www.urge.org.nz website. Work alongside relevant organisations so that I can be informed of the issues and identify opportunities for support
Change of the legal drinking age needs to be accompanied with adequate funding to support educational programmes on responsible use of alcohol and accessible drug and alcohol rehabilitation programmes.
I support decriminalisation of cannabis only if adequate funding is made available to promote the prevention/risks of use by children and teenagers, facilities are available in the community for young people to get advice and support for drug problems and heavy penalties are put in place for supply/growing of cannabis that is not for personal use.
(i)Regulations and restrictions need to be placed on the availability of cannabis as opposed to it being freely available (which I consider it is now). (ii) Controls on the growing of cannabis for personal use i.e. a limited number of plants as opposed to any commercial activity. (iii) Controls on possessing cannabis -what is considered personal use as opposed to supply.
I would support that Maori health service be provided and managed by Maori for Maori.
I am supportive of consumer involvement in mental health. Sharing a personal experience of a health system probably gives some of the best insights into what is needed.
I see health promotion as a top priority and would support local body funding of health promotion.
I would support targeted local body funding for health promotion.
Denise Henigan verbatim
NCC
Continue to support such things as the Youth Involvement Package. Promote the need for alcohol free activities appropriate for youth. I support the establishment of a Youth Park and skating bowl.
Yes it needs to be reviewed.
~
Decriminalisation means someone possessing a small amount of cannabis wont be prosecuted. Legalisation - making the cultivation, possession and supply of cannabis a legal activity.
~
~
Very high, the promotion of healthy lifestyle choices is vital. Councils, businesses, governments also need to be lobbied to ake into consideration the health benefits of good life style options right at the beginning of the planning process, not added on at the end as an after thought. eg new roads. As more people die from illnesses that are the consequence of lifestyle options, so does the need for the promotion of of healthy options.
Derek Shaw verbatim
NCC
Encourage the provision of alcohol-free events and facilities for YP. Improve enforcement of the SoL Act. Encourage youth workers to assist those YP who overindulge in alcohol.
Need more info on the extent of alcohol abuse by 18+ year olds and under-age drinkers to determine whether it is an enforcement or education problem.
I don't think it should be a "criminal offence" to possess small quantities of cannabis. I'm also concerned about the adverse health effects of cannabis, alcohol and nicotine on people, including YP.
Decriminalisation means that it would not be a criminal offence to possess small quantities. Legalisation would send a signal that cannabis is an acceptable substance.
Should largely be for Maori to decide.
A good idea.
High.
Dorothy Mathews verbatim
DHB
Extend community led health promotion and support systems. Targeted education in schools. Early identification of YP with problems. Buddy systems for YP. Give priority to Child & Adolescent Mental Health Service.
SoL Act should be carefully monitored to see if [ it] is being enforced or abused. The new legislation could work if the above support systems are in place.
Decriminalised. But still illegal except in special medical-based circumstances.
Decriminalisation reduces its use from a crime - life-time blot on a YP's record, to a misdemeanour such as a traffic infringement, which is not a permanent branding, & therefore more appropriate.
Equal access and opportunity - as with all communities who have the same rights to be consulted. I understand that iwi have entered into partnership contracts to provide certain services in Nelson/Marlborough.
The Mental Health & Privacy Acts should be reviewed. Both patients and the public have the right to be protected and informed.
Top priority. With a health promoting hospital being developed in Nelson it is essential that it be linked to a Health promoting community.
Elaine Henry verbatim
TDC
Education, education, education.
If 20 years is too old, and 18 years is too young, what's the matter with 19 years as the minimum age.
We need a lot more debate on this issue first. Debate should be informed rather than on preconceived notions.
Decriminalisation: you may be fined but it is not a crime. Legalisation - perfectly legal to use cannabis with no penalty incurred.
Should be funded by DHBs in response to plan devised by Maori for Maori & anyone else who wishes to use this service.
Consumers should be involved in making informed decisions about their mental health.
High priority.
Name
Candidate for ...
1. What would you do to minimise alcohol-related harm for young people in this region?
2. What stance do you take regarding the review of the drinking age (Sale of Liquor Act) ?
3. What do you think the legal status of cannabis should be in NZ?
4. What do you see as the differences between decriminalisation and legalisation of cannabis?
5. What is your view on Maori health service provision in the Nelson region?
6. What is your view on consumer involvement in mental health?
7. What priority do you give health promotion for the well-being of New Zealanders?
Other comments
Eric Davy verbatim
NCC
Encourage a more proactive role by Council towards this problem. There are obviously underlying issues that need addressing. Also the NCC should be working more closely with the Police to identify establishments or people who encourage the excess of drinking for the profit motive.
The age limit should be reverted to 20yrs. This should never have been lowered. This action encouraged the younger people to seek out sources of alcohol. There was nobody around to mentor them or give guidance.
I would not support any move to make this drug legal. It is the first step to trying other drugs and any person who believes it has no permanent harm is irresponsible. Many people have got away with it and like smokers they will never go back.
In my occupation I am well aware of the difference between the two. Is exceeding 50kph illegal? Yes. Is it a criminal offence? No. If the speed goes up to Speed Dangerous then it becomes a criminal offence.
I do not have any knowledge at this time to answer this question.
This must be handled better than it is. Education is the key as many people are scared through ignorance as to the possible actions of mentally ill persons.
Simple. If you do not have good health your quality of life reduces. Education must be used to greater effect and more frequently. To often people do not want to hear about sick people in case it rubs off against them.
Gail Collingwood verbatim
NCC
Suggest DHB put money into after-party/rave support for attendees & that DHB employ additional counsellors who have specific skills for working with individual YP within schools.
Should be reviewed & statistical evidence collected NZ-wide to see if any changes are needed.
As is, no change. Watched the loss of brain power & stunting of personal development of a 30 year old who has used & grown since teenage years. Will they contribute to society in their 50's.
One is court & record related, and the other is making it like tobacco.
I understand there are many specific projects funded for Maori health in Nelson, such as MWW project at Stoke.
If the consumer is well enough they need to be involved and it would depend on intellectual ability also as to the extent of the involvement.
Health promotion is important grass roots stuff, but people have to be prepared to look & listen and some are busy living the high life to take notice.
Garry Watson verbatim
Set in place areas for the young to have fun in a responsible manner. Many are just bored, they can't handle stress and feel isolated. I have many ideas to address this.
It's not the age I have a problem with but individual's maturity.
Kept illegal, but focus on helping addicts.
It's the difference between how serious the issue is. A person using cannabis for their own use is different to a person supplying school children.
Unfortunately the culture has some clashes with health, and until the real issues are addressed it will be an uphill battle.
Mental health is a community responsibility and we must be more tolerant to merge people into society. Some must be restrained.
I support & practice healthy living. We need to educate & show people tips so vegetables and fruit are not boring. Show the benefits of exercise etc.
Gay Northcott verbatim
DHB
To minimise alcohol-related harm I would encourage ongoing education into the effects of alcohol and also encourage activities for youth which will help them feel wanted and lessen the need for them to drink, e.g. Drug Arm and youth activity centres.
I think that the lowering of the drinking age was a mistake as many of the young drinkers do not have the maturity to manage alcohol safely.
I think that legalising cannabis in NZ is sending signals to YP that it is a safe drug and ignores the potential damage that cannabis can cause especially to the young.
Both of these terms give the message that cannabis is safe to use. Therefore I do not like the use of either.
Health statistics show that Maori health needs are greater than those of the general population therefore there is a need to focus on the specific health needs of Maori in the Nelson Region.
As in all areas, I see consumer involvement to be essential as the consumers are the people most affected by the health decisions made.
I strongly believe that the more we can promote healthy lifestyles the less need there is for the more acute and costly health services.
Gaye Evans verbatim
DHB
Improve education programmes
I think you should be able to legally drink at 18 yrs
Legalise for those over the age of 18
Legalisation means that it can be more openly & better controlled by govt agencies. No longer controlled by criminal elements.
I do not have enough knowledge in this area to form an opinion.
It would depend on the severity of the disease/disability, but on the whole I think that we should be as involved in mental health as we are in physical health.
Very high priority.
George Truman verbatim
DHB
Policing and prosecution of sales and re-sales to minors. Education by peer-group plays in secondary schools
Issue and insist on photo ID as originally envisaged when drinking age reduction was contemplated.
Still illegal but spot fines without conviction for possession or personal quantity.
NZ could decriminalise the smoking by individuals (by introducing spot fines without conviction), but still maintain present illegality of growing and dealing.
Keen on Maori helping Maori (e.g. smoking cessation programme), and would like this principle extended into immunisation, well child, home care and mental health, but unless a greater need is evident, at no more funding per capita than non-Maori.
Separate meetings and forums of consumers, then the consensus, or strongly held minority view, conveyed by effective communicators to the decision makers.
Absolute top priority of the DHB, as this will produce the best return on outlay in the long run. Different methods for different groups, e.g. Men's Health.
Gordon Currie verbatim
DHB
Raise the legal drinking age. More police on night patrol. More education on drinking available in colleges. Harsher penalties.
Return the age of consent to 21 years. With severe penalties to any liquor retailer breaking the law.
Illegal drug
Disaster, if either is contemplated in NZ.
We are all NZ'ers and health care will be given without prejudice.
Profit in any shape or form has no place in any of our health services, but unfortunately, this is happening.
Top priority.
Hanne Bjorklund - abridged
TDC Moutere Waimea
Youth / children must be taught how to develop self esteem, inner resources, independence, courage to say no. No one ever liked their first drink or cigarette. Kids start from peer pressure.
Who ever lowered the drinking age were idiots. It was a heavily lobbied decision, and it only serves as a gift to the liquor industry. Passing that law amounted almost to a criminal act. The age should be raised.
Don't know. It's so easily available now, that its legal status may not make much difference, even though I do believe that being illegal, curbs the usage to some extent. I would like to see the young being so strong within themselves that they simply won't need or want any type of drug.
Not much. If it's legal the price may drop, and dope-related crime may go down, but usage would increase. Something similar may happen with decriminalisation. I would not choose to fly in an aeroplane that had been serviced by a cannabis smoker.
I do not know a great deal about this issue. But why have two separate health services? Aren't we all just one people? The health system should provide a high level of service for everyone who needs it.
I do not understand what you mean by consumer involvement.
I think this issue should have high priority. It is a lot less expensive to run a health system for healthy people. However, ultimately health is the responsibility of each individual, so we must ensure that children are aware of the importance of good health, how to achieve and maintain it. Sadly, many do not have good examples at home. Why not try to develop just one generation of "good" parents.
Harvey Ruru verbatim
NMDHB
Encourage more funding from the hospitality industry to promote "walk the talkers", people who will promote safe and responsible drinking including local resources when the people need assistance. Including continuing education programmes in schools, colleges, kohanga reo in early intervention.
There should always be continual reviews of this Act and many other Acts. The constant research and monitoring will give us trends and better information on where to target proactive initiatives.
I endorse the stance of the Chairperson of the NZ Maori Council.
Decriminalisation far outweighs legislation. That is why I endorse the stance of the NZ Maori Council.
More needs to be achieved in this region. The statistics are appalling and we are still very dependant on a monocultural service, which is not delivering appropriately.
I'm an advocate for more consumer/tangata whaiora involvement in mental health and personally work in this area.
I want better health for my mokopuna today. Health promotion today is the only way this can happen, especially in the home and with more health $$$.
Name
Candidate for ...
1. What would you do to minimise alcohol-related harm for young people in this region?
2. What stance do you take regarding the review of the drinking age (Sale of Liquor Act) ?
3. What do you think the legal status of cannabis should be in NZ?
4. What do you see as the differences between decriminalisation and legalisation of cannabis?
5. What is your view on Maori health service provision in the Nelson region?
6. What is your view on consumer involvement in mental health?
7. What priority do you give health promotion for the well-being of New Zealanders?
Other comments
Helen Lees verbatim
NCC
Education programmes in schools and into the homes especially the drink/driving message. Have gigs etc. which are alcohol free. Getting across that all important message - that you don't need to drink to be cool!
In health terms, I think it was a retrograde step. I understand that it been proven that the younger the age when alcohol is first consumed the greater the likelihood of addiction to alcohol.
Decriminalisation for over 20's only.
Legalisation = free & openly available. Decriminalisation - not acceptable to society but not branded as a criminal. Decriminalisation must be accompanied by education on health/safety risks associated with drug taking. Ideally programmes covering alcohol and drug (including smoking) education should be priority health education initiatives.
As Maori health standards / life expectancy is well below the rest of the population education initiatives to improve Maori health and nutrition should be given a high priority. Although, of course, not to the detriment of other essential health services.
Mental health services, or lack of, have caused much distress to families in NZ in recent years. Mental health affects many NZ'ers and their families. The assimilation of patients, who have previously been cared for at Braemar or Ngawhatu, into community housing needs to be given a fair share of resources, staffing and the health funding budget. As a member of Victim Support, our national body, is very mindful of the needs and rights of mental health victims and their families.
A high priority from babyhood to the elderly.
Helen Rance by phone
DHB Richmond
As member of Health Action Trust Board, feel it is a conflict of interest to respond to this forum. I support the kaupapa & mahi of Health Action Trust.
Ian McLauchlan verbatim
NMDHB
Youth & alcohol. More emphasis on education re. responsible drinking, the harmful effects on mind and body. Strategies to deal with peer pressure, advice to young people on how to look after their friends who drink too much, and role modelling from adults on drinking in a safe and responsible manner. Provide entertainment in alcohol-free venues. Pressure the pubs/bottle stores who sell to underage drinkers.
I feel 18 is a reasonable age, this may be me showing a bias as it's always been the legal age in Scotland where I grew up. However I think it correlates well to leaving school, getting a job & accepting adult responsibility
I personally think it should be decriminalised. This would make it a health and education issue rather than a justice matter.
Decriminalisation is about minimising the harm it causes. Legalisation is about making cannabis an industry, profit making and taxation dollars for the Govt.
I don't have sufficient knowledge to make an informed comment. If it's the same as other parts of NZ it is likely to be inadequate to meet the needs of Maori.
I have worked in Mental health for nearly 20 years. Consumer involvement is paid lip service much of the time and it's a crime. Whenever I have worked with organisations who truly involve consumers it has been spectacularly successful, e.g. 2nd Chance, Zoodoo. It is a shame not to use the expertise available within the consumer groups.
Top priority. Health Budgets are finite and treatment costs keep on growing. The only feasible way to deal with this imbalance is to increase the health status of the whole population. Some efforts are being made but more has to be done. It needs a higher priority. Mental Health is not discussed sufficiently at school or as a health issue in general. Mental illness is only an issue when it is headline news after someone is killed, it's a little too late by then. Stigma and discrimination can be defeated by education and personal contact, consumers who are willing to work in this area are a resource which is undervalued and under-utilised.
Jack Ward verbatim
NCC
Make parents more responsible
Age back to 20
No
Very minimal
Good
Good
Higher nurses wages. Try & bring down the waiting lists.
Jan Fryer verbatim
NCC
Education on the effects of alcohol must be a priority. Along with that must be responsibility on both the youth's part & their parents. The consequences of their actions must be accepted by them.
I would like to see it raised again.
As it currently stands, i.e. Status Quo
Decriminalisation means you won't be prosecuted necessarily for possession of cannabis, but it is still not legal to grow, sell etc. Legalisation means making it a legal commodity along the same lines as alcohol.
Very adequate.
I'm afraid I do not know a great deal about it.
Very high, although it is not a specific local body issue, but definitely one for Area Health Boards to consider.
Jo Raine verbatim
NCC
Try & get parents to be more responsible for YP.
Lift the age to 20 (and penalise throughout the courts) anyone providing alcohol to minors.
Illegal - why add another poison?
I don't approve of either - decriminalisation just turns a blind eye.
I have no special information on Maori health - it is not a City Council area of expertise.
Do not understand the question.
People could and should take more personal responsibility.
Joe Bell verbatim
Golden Bay Community Board
More education about dangers of excessive alcohol consumption (i.e. foetal syndrome); raise drinking age back to 20 (sensible exceptions could provide for a glass of wine with family meals under parental supervision etc.), hit sellers and other suppliers hard who are convicted of supplying to minors; raise taxes on alcohol to both deter and better reflect the cost of excessive alcohol consumption on our community i.e. social dislocation, health, 'accidents', crime etc.
With a few exceptions, return it to age 20.
I am very concerned about health implications of youth using cannabis and others who have become heavily dependent on it. Perhaps it could be decriminalised for those over 20 in some situations i.e. for pain relief by prescription, however, I would need to be convinced of the pros and cons of this. The REASONS why people seek 'escape' through drink and drugs also need to be addressed to try to determine 'cause and effect'.
Decriminalisation' in this instance means that possession of small amounts of cannabis for personal use would not be illegal. It is a step away from 'legalisation' which would see dealers, or those possessing quantities of the drug for supply, selling openly with impunity.
There needs to be targeted education programmes to try to improve Maori health outcomes through prevention. Smoking related disease is still a big problem for example. However, access to health care should be equitable across the whole community as far as is possible.
Mental Health often appears to be the 'poor relation' in the provision of adequate resources which can have tragic results for the individual, their family and the wider community. Trained staff and adequate facilities must be allocated to cater for a wide range of needs in both hospital and community care. In Golden Bay there seems to be community support for Te Whare Mahana and other mental health providers.
A very high priority to education for preventative or 'green prescription' together with adequate resources aimed at providing the best possible care and timely treatment when this is necessary. i.e. 'fence' first backed by a reliable 'ambulance'.
John Rodgers verbatim
TDC Richmond
Strictly enforce the age limit re drinking of alcohol. Provide easily accessible alternative activities e.g. the proposed Richmond leisure pool. A youth club could be established adjacent to the pool and incorporate other activities such as a climbing wall.
This is a matter for parliament but greater funding for ALAC would see an increased educational programme to change all New Zealanders' attitudes to alcohol.
This is matter for parliament to decide. Legalisation could create more problems than it resolves.
Decriminalisation means that possessing small amounts of cannabis or growing a few plants for personal use would not be classed as a criminal activity whereas growing and packaging for sale would be illegal.
I really don't know a lot about this subject except that if an especially tailored approach would improve Maori health then it should be pursued.
We are not managing mental health services well and clearly not enough notice is being taken of their care givers viz the recent case in Dunedin where a young man murdered his mother. Some patients can live in the community with appropriate care but others may need to be institutionalised for their happiness and for the safety of the community.
New Zealanders need to take more care of their own health by giving up smoking, getting more exercise and understanding nutrition. This will reduce the ever increasing demand for health services and perhaps make health service provision manageable
Judy Crow abridged
DHB Nelson
I would recognise the NZ Health Strategy and the requirement for all the DHBs to follow the key goals and objectives of this strategy. One of these goals is to minimise the harm by alcohol, illicit and other drugs. My responsibilities on this issue would be to consider all the facts and recommendations put before me and to act with honesty, integrity, care, diligence and skill in making the most appropriate decision.
I am constantly reminding myself that as a member of the NMDHB that I have to put my own personal stance aside and act as outlined in the previous question.
Once again, as a DHB member my personal opinion is not the guiding force, but rather evidence based information and acting as required by the NZ Public Health & Disability Act 2000.
Decriminalisation effectively means that if a person was "found" in the possession of or using cannabis, they could be given a "spot fine" (similar to a parking infringement or speeding ticket) but they would not have a criminal record as a result. Legalisation means it would be legal to possess or smoke cannabis and the person would not even get a "spotfine" as in the previous situation i.e. cannabis would be treated along the same lines as tobacco now is.
As outlined in the Maori Health Strategy the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi - partnership, participation, protection apply. Clear direction under the NZ P H & D Act 2000 - a DHB is required to reduce health disparities by improving outcomes for Maori, to establish and maintain processes to enable Maori to participate/contribute to strategies for Maori Health improvement. To foster Maori participation in health/provide for the needs of Maori.
A DHB is required to develop strong consumer participation networks to support and inform the plan development processes. Stronger participation by consumers to ensure the Mental Health Strategy and plans, stay focused on meeting consumers' needs in ways which deliver the best outcomes for them. Stronger participation by families.
A DHB is required to adopt the objectives of the NZ Health Strategy. Thirteen goals are listed, all of which will involve a huge health promotion component, for them to be achieved. Therefore the priority of Health promotion will be high under this present health structure.
I have not answered these questions on a personal opinion basis, but on the basis of how I would view the question as a current team member on the DHB.
Name
Candidate for ...
1. What would you do to minimise alcohol-related harm for young people in this region?
2. What stance do you take regarding the review of the drinking age (Sale of Liquor Act) ?
3. What do you think the legal status of cannabis should be in NZ?
4. What do you see as the differences between decriminalisation and legalisation of cannabis?
5. What is your view on Maori health service provision in the Nelson region?
6. What is your view on consumer involvement in mental health?
7. What priority do you give health promotion for the well-being of New Zealanders?
Other comments
Judy Greer verbatim
DHB
In a DHB role, my emphasis would be in health promotion related to alcohol & in exploring ways to address the alcohol culture.
My concern is addressing the culture of drinking for YP & other groups.
Decriminalised.
Decriminalisation would minimise the risk of YP acquiring criminal records at a time of life when they are most vulnerable.
I have been active in developing the vision for Maori Mental Health and believe that Maori Health services should be more fully resourced. Access to more skilled work training is a key issue.
I am actively involved with consumers/tangata whaiora in projects, assessments, quality issues.
High priority. As chair of the Mental Health Association, we have a focus on health promotion which has resulted in the Mental Health Expos over the past 4 years, as well as the up-coming focus on "creativity & wellness".
K F Williamson verbatim
DHB Richmond
The existing law is fine, however it must be enforced. Society needs to examine procurement. Who is supplying those under 18 years of age? They should be prosecuted. It is not a problem with the Nelson/Marlborough region only, it is a national concern.
18 yr olds are generally responsible young adults. The law must be enforced. Under 18-year olds who are found the "worse for wear" due to alcohol, must be "forced" to provide the source of their supply. The suppliers, whether parents, older peers or liquor outlets, must be held accountable.
The status quo should remain. There is too little valid information to consider any change. I have seen its effects on people of all ages.
Decriminalisation would mean an offender would not be labelled for life for a one-off offence. Multiple offences would need further consideration. It would probably lead to increased production. Existing legislation inhibits the production of cannabis for sale and supply, but sends it underground and involves criminal elements.
Poumanawa Oranga - the Maori development organisation is doing fine work in education of iwi, Maori communities, whanau and hapu. Annette King's 13-point health objectives are relevant to all communities, not just Maori. However, Maori do have a higher incidence of some diseases, e.g. diabetes. Education, through proactive consultation is one answer.
Currently there is one advisor. More consumer advisors would have significant benefits... they should be on a contract to provide security of tenure for long -term planning. Clients need to be listened to.
We are all responsible for our own lives. Well-care, from diet to exercise, should be give constant & high priority in terms of promotion.
Kevin Wilkes verbatim
NCC
There is not a lot that can be done to minimise alcohol-related harm for young people, the only thing that can be done is to provide education to the parents as well as the young people. It is relatively easy for young people to gain access to alcohol and it is up to themselves or their parents to be able to control their drinking. There are many things that could be done such a zero tolerance to inebriation in public, no congregating in certain areas, but would these type of things work or make them worse.
There are a lot of issues that need to be resolved regarding the drinking age. It is not the lowered drinking age that is the problem, but the youth themselves. Also I believe the driving age should be raised to eighteen and there should be zero tolerance to drink driving
Cannabis should be illegal in NZ
Decriminalisation and legalisation of cannabis is basically the same thing, making cannabis legal to be used and sold.
Although I am not fully up on what health services are available for Maori I believe there is a need to provide health promotion to not only Maori but all New Zealanders, especially people on the low socio-economic scale. There is a need to provide more awareness of health risks Maori might be at risk, such as diabetes, heart disease, etc.
Mental health is very important, but the problem is there are not enough facilities for young people with mental illnesses, also there is a need to make mental illness more public and take away the stigma of having a mental illness. There are many factors that relate to mental illness and it is hard to answer this question. Nelson has a very strong focus on mental health and have provided certain facilities to accommodate people with a mental illness. But as has been portrayed in the media there has been an increase in suicide, especially depression related, there needs to be more awareness that mental health is not in the mind but has been attributed to a chemical disorder in the body.
Health promotion is extremely important as it makes people more aware of not only their well being but gives them a better understanding of the risks they may be taking by not seeking medical help, living a dangerous lifestyle or just not being aware of any health issues they have not resolved.
Kim Merry verbatim
DHB
Institute youth friendly policies and education programmes targeted at young people.
Look at bringing the age back to 20 or screen heavily for IDs at purchase places. Alongside an examination of the societal acceptance and tolerance of drinking and drunkeness.
Decriminilised.
Decriminilisation helps alleviate the social issues. Legalisation condones usage.
As a non-Maori I don't feel able to comment.
Positive view overall. The consumer involvement is of great importance as it allows accountability
A high priority.
Liz Richards verbatim
DHB Tasman
More education for YP & their parents & for rest of population. Kiwi's attitude to drinking is not healthy - binge drinking too widely acceptable. More positive role modelling is needed - for everyone's health and well-being.
Now legal age reduced to 18, probably better to keep it at 18 but see answer to Q 1. Educate, discuss, and encourage sensible drinking behaviour, and make sure enforcement of the current SoL Act is properly carried out.
_
Decriminalisation means that someone being caught using cannabis should not receive a criminal record - but might still be fined/have the cannabis confiscated, as the cannabis would still be illegal. If legalised the growing, marketing, sale and use of cannabis would be allowed - much as alcohol use is now - i.e. would be a legal drug.
Important to support "For Maori, By Maori" - improving level of provision in region, but removing financial barriers for low income people is essential.
Very valuable to have consumer involvement - need to have appropriate support and training for those involved.
Very high priority. Process of enabling people to take control of the factors that affect their health is essential. New legislation is a move in the right direction - requires community involvement & intersectoral cooperation. Emphasis on prevention is crucial to our long term health.
Lois McTaggart verbatim
TDC
a) antenatal education programmes aimed at informing women and the public of the dangers to the foetus of alcohol consumption during pregnancy. Postnatal education programmes aimed at supporting, promoting and protecting breastfeeding up to 6 mths. b) Teaching youth and families the benefits of drinking in sociable / acceptable ways, developing these programmes to change attitudes toward alcohol and drugs, as have been changed toward smoking. c) Funding for e.g.. anger management courses, youth intervention programmes, drink-drive education, women's refuge and women's link programmes.
I prefer the age of legal drinking raised to 20 years.
I am unable to answer this question completely. I am very concerned about the health effects, particularly mental well-being, that cannabis use yields, yet recognise the widespread cultivation and use of cannabis in NZ. In an effort to change behaviours and attitudes toward cannabis use, I support debate about decriminalisation of cannabis. Cannabis use for medical purposes appears to have merit, for example, relieving chronic pain, and the use of cannabis under strict medical and legal guidelines may be acceptable
I support further discussion of these two concepts as a way to understand the reasons behind the use of cannabis in NZ.
I believe Maori health provision needs developing.
This question is not so clear. Do you mean in the provision of mental health services? I believe, where possible, consumer involvement in mental health services and provision of those services, is desirable.
Top priority, along with other health initiative priorities
My position as a health professional is to promote and develop an attitudinal change in NZers toward prevention, rather than intervention, where possible, in health. Health affects us all, and permeates all aspects of life.
Mary-Ellen O'Connor verbatim
DHB
Provide more activities for youth. Continued education about dangers, esp drink-driving. Have fewer liquor outlets
I feel it should not have been lowered.
Research seems to prove that cannabis can be harmful when taken over time. I think it should remain illegal.
Decriminalisation implies that if someone is found to have a little cannabis for personal use, it is not regarded as a criminal offence. Legalisation implies that it has society's complete stamp of approval.
I support the devolution of funding and provision. But there has to be accountability for the funding and support for the Maori health workforce to provide a professional health service. At this stage it seems that health outcomes for Maori are not necessarily improving.
This is a basic human right, and is in fact a demand under the Code of Rights, administered and developed by the Health & Disability Commission.
Obviously far greater priority should be given. This is both the theory - - the Principles of the Ottawa Charter - and also easily documented in practice. If more money was spent on primary health care, the system would save millions of dollars. E.g. Q1 - alcohol related harm to YP. If we could save the money in the tertiary sector, we could do so much more.
Michael Higgins verbatim
TDC Moutere
I would encourage youth leadership & youth activities to occupy young people in a healthy environment & way of life. Encourage the family unit, & healthy family living. Avoiding the abuse of alcohol is a choice, every day.
Lowering the drinking age has been damaging to our youth. I would support remedies if I knew what they were.
It should remain a criminal offence. I have found that cannabis is a mind-changing and destructive substance.
Technically there is a difference, but in effect I believe there is little or no difference.
I don't know anything on this point. Health provision generally is benefiting from increasing community input.
I don't particularly understand this Qn as it relates to consumer.
A high priority - the concept of healthy living and healthy minds is very important.
Mike Cotton verbatim
NCC
As YP grow from 14 or 15 through to 17 & 18 year olds they start drinking alcohol. It has been like this for a very long time. How you teach youngsters to drink in moderation and remain responsible - very difficult. Drinking in a controlled environment is preferable to boozing up in a park or the beach. Proof of age makes this difficult.
I personally believe 20 yrs is the correct age to drink in bars. However, in sports clubs etc., a more liberal approach should be possible , i.e. controlled environment even age 17-20, sports clubs usually look after their younger members.
Illegal !
If cannabis is legalised you might as well legalise all drugs.
No view.
Strange question?
Very important. The green prescription from a GP needs promoting. More exercise, better diet is needed.
Name
Candidate for ...
1. What would you do to minimise alcohol-related harm for young people in this region?
2. What stance do you take regarding the review of the drinking age (Sale of Liquor Act) ?
3. What do you think the legal status of cannabis should be in NZ?
4. What do you see as the differences between decriminalisation and legalisation of cannabis?
5. What is your view on Maori health service provision in the Nelson region?
6. What is your view on consumer involvement in mental health?
7. What priority do you give health promotion for the well-being of New Zealanders?
Other comments
Murray Ruddenklau verbatim
NCC
Promote and support Alcohol-free recreation. E.g. Murphy type facilities.
Campaign for the lifting of the age limit to minimum 20 years.
Should not be legalised.
Should not be accepted as a norm in society.
Existing organisations need more publicity & support. Council should help to support this.
Press govt for more support to provide more personnel especially in acute areas.
this requires Top priority. People have the right to be and remain well.
Pat O'Shea verbatim
TDC Motueka
This harm comes in different guises but I presume you mean harm from alcohol use by young people - if so, we need to involve young people in developing strategies to deal with this.
I think it needs reviewing regularly. However it is attitudes to drinking that are important rather than legislation.
Decriminalise. If we compare it with alcohol there are some bizarre anomalies - I would like to see cannabis decriminalised.
Legalisation may be more than we can cope with at present. Decriminalisation would remove the prospect of criminal records for thousands of recreational users. I would personally like to see a way of regulating or controlling trade in cannabis.
I don't have much knowledge of this. Maori should be very much in charge of these services and should have adequate resources provided to deliver them.
Makes sense, where practical, to involve those who receive services in the planning of these services.
High
Paul Rosanowski verbatim
NCC
Education of our children is very important. It can never be too early to have programs for young people showing them the potential danger they will face as they grow.
Age 18 limit has caused short term problems. It should continue however high school education should be increased to advice on the affects of alcohol. Strict rules on publicans should be enforced with large fines imposed for selling liquor to minors.
Cannabis should continue to be an illegal drug in NZ.
Decriminalisation will allow the police to give people instant fines if found with the drug. Legalisation will allow it to be sold publicly
I have no comment on this area as I have not had any direct involvement in Maori health issues.
I am concerned that we are putting some people back into the community before they may be ready. The loss of major institutions will allow smaller pockets of people into the community and they may not be in an environment that fits their needs
I would promote education as being a major key for the well-being of New Zealanders. If we have a society that is more informed and understand the messages then health and well-being will be part of the benefit gained.
Phillip Chapman verbatim
DHB
Keep up and increase promotion, education and support for them.
Always good to review things. It depends who reviews, and what you do with it, often.
Decriminalisation, then review.
Legalisation - regulated product, open market and all that it entails. Govt could earn cuts of cost out of this. Decriminalisation - Minor offences. Civil not criminal.
Public health is starting to employ more Maori health workers, Paperwork would suggest all is well, I wonder if it is just lip services at times.
The Public Health Unit is starting to use consumer involvement . This is the track they need to follow - if you want to know what people want, ASK them.
top of my list. Don't blame. Back to the drawing board to find out the many aspects of well-being.
Ray Caird verbatim
DHB Tasman
More info re: the effects of both alcohol and cannabis, and what happens when they're mixed. Improved availability of counselling services.
I would like to see the present law change reviewed in light of evidence to date.
Decriminalise for private use only. Harsh penalties for marketing and trading the drug.
Decriminalisation for private use only.
Seek to improve, but remember that Maori are only 8% of the Nelson region compared to perhaps 20% plus, in other N.I. areas where need is greater.
Absolutely essential that this area is represented in Community Health Boards. It's also an important public health issue.
Top priority to increase funding needs more attention, and will save many dollars off our health bill in the long term.
Richard Johns verbatim
TDC Mayoral
Try to get council to introduce a zero tolerance to under-age drinking while providing an environment to give alternatives.
I feel lowering the age was a mistake.
Illegal. Possible limited medical use?
Decriminalisation partial acceptance. Legalisation total acceptance.
National issue, not a local council issue. No comment.
National issue. No comment.
National issue. No comment.
Richard Kempthorne verbatim
TDC
a)Promote good family life, good interfamily relationships and provide help for at risk families. Provide help for solo parent families. b)Have activities for young people that don't involve alcohol e.g. well supervised socials or dances, skate boarding, rock climbing walls, paintball, youth group activities etc. c)Try to avoid access for early teens being able to buy alcoholic drinks.
I would like to see the drinking age of eighteen enforced. If this age cannot be enforced then I think the drinking age (the age someone can buy alcoholic drinks) should be lifted to twenty. I don't oppose responsible drinking at home with the family.
I think it should remain illegal and a criminal offence to use cannabis. If cannabis is decriminalised then this would send a clear signal that drug use is OK. I don't think it is. I oppose recreational drug use.
Decriminalisation - whether it is a criminal offence to use cannabis. Cannabis use could be illegal but decriminalised, however I think this is a copout and opens the door for drug use - I oppose it.
I don't know enough about the Maori health service in Nelson, however this is a legitimate of the health service that needs to be suitably acknowledged and work.
From an outsiders point of view, mental health seems to be under-funded, sometimes seriously. The mentally ill should have adequately funded and properly run mental health care provided for them.
It is essential to have an adequate basic public health service funded by the government. This doesn't mean that all health care, regardless of cost, is available publicly, but the basics should be.
Sharon Brindson verbatim
DHB
That's a tough one. I haven't got any answers that are not already being tried. Education, support the provision of alternative activities, ensure youth-oriented counselling and A&D services exist, collaboration between schools and health.
I had reservations about lowering the drinking age so favour a review. Although it may not be causal figures from A&E show an increase in alcohol-related harm in this age group occurring since the drinking age was lowered.(Unofficial communication to Health Needs Assessment Committee).
I am not 100% sure. I probably support decriminalisation of possession but NOT supply (determined by quantity). There are pros and cons of legalisation. It's use is widespread in spite of it's legal status. Putting it on a more realistic footing may well allow more effective education and measures to minimise harm. When I listen to debates on the subject, representatives of the maori community and school principals seem to be strongly opposed to further liberalisation which does give me pause for thought.
Decriminalisation relates to the severity of the crime and hence sentence and record for possession or use. Legalisation relates to the status of the drug itself (e.g. alcohol is a legal drug cannabis is not, some party drugs are and some aren't).
The growth of by maori for maori services is good and should be supported. There should be (and are) mechanisms whereby mainstream delivery is improved to Maori clients. More can always be done in this regard. Maori health service provision should (and does) include prevention, lifestyle and the wider determinants of health.
It is both mandatory and absolutely desirable
A very high priority. I don't really like the word promotion . I prefer something that conveys enabling/facilitating people to take responsibility for prevention and healthy lifestyle choices but it's probably splitting hairs
Tim King verbatim
TDC
Continue to support groups working with YP. Encourage parents to be more aware of their children's activities. It's really an education and attitude issue, not something you can legislate for.
I agree with lowering the drinking age but stricter adherence to the limit should be enforced.
Remain illegal.
Decriminalisation would mean those caught using cannabis could still be fined etc. but wouldn't receive a criminal record whereas legalisation would mean no enforcement of cannabis related activities at all.
Health provision in Nelson is in comparison with other parts of the country in good shape. I believe Maori Health enjoys the same standard. I don't know enough to be more specific.
I believe mental health suffers from the same problem as many NZ bureaucracies. One minute it's [all?] institutions, then all community care. Never seems to be a balance. More public input would help even out the swings from one philosophy to another.
Top priority. An ambulance at the bottom of the cliff is no substitute for a sound fence at the top.
Trevor Norris verbatim
Better education programmes.
I have not supported the lowering of the drinking age.
Do not support any change.
I do not support either option. Any thing that frees up the availability of cannabis is a backward step.
As a parent of part Maori children, I believe service provision is good. I do not support separate health provision for separate races. We should all be treated equally.
We should listen more to the people who can tell horrific stories of the inadequate suppport provided to families who are confronted with these problems.
A high priority, along with education.
Name
Candidate for ...
1. What would you do to minimise alcohol-related harm for young people in this region?
2. What stance do you take regarding the review of the drinking age (Sale of Liquor Act) ?
3. What do you think the legal status of cannabis should be in NZ?
4. What do you see as the differences between decriminalisation and legalisation of cannabis?
5. What is your view on Maori health service provision in the Nelson region?
6. What is your view on consumer involvement in mental health?
7. What priority do you give health promotion for the well-being of New Zealanders?
Other comments
Last Updated on 20/09/01
By Health Action Trust
Email us